Articles | September 27, 2024

Building Trades: Health & Financial Security Matter to Women

The construction industry recognizes that women are a critical talent pipeline to address the continued shortage of skilled workers. The federal government does, too. The Commerce Department has created what it calls a CHIPS Women in Construction Framework as part of its Million Women in Construction initiative, which aims to double the number of women in construction over the next decade.

The challenges are how to recruit women to the building trades and encourage them to stay in the industry.

Building Trade Health Financial Security Matter to Women

To be able to make a strong case for women to join the construction industry and remain there, learn what women who are working in the building trades say they like about their career choice: the financial stability provided by a well-paying job with great benefits — specifically, personal health, financial wellness and retirement readiness.

The financial security these benefits provide is a powerful incentive.

What women say about working in construction

Smiling Mature Woman Sitting On Her Patio Drinking WaterWe interviewed 10 women apprentices in the building trades to learn what attracted new recruits to the industry and to hear about their experiences working in construction. All of them were drawn to the work for the competitive pay, strong benefits and financial security. As one apprentice said, “You’re set up with insurance and you know when you retire, you’re going to be OK.” To hear from these women apprentices in their own words, watch excerpts from the interviews.

Kilah Engelke, founder of the nonprofit EmpowHER Institute, who started in a trade and is now on the board of the Wisconsin Regional Training Partnership, also expressed enthusiasm for the benefits of working in construction when she spoke earlier this year to Julie Su, Acting Secretary of Labor. As summarized in a DOL blog post, Ms. Engelke said, “My experience as a tradeswoman has shaped my life. It has allowed me to live my dreams while building my pension and having the best healthcare available.” She also noted:

I have made great money as a cement mason, allowing me to own my own house, have nice vehicles, have amazing life experiences, be independent and not have to rely on anyone else besides myself, all while building my pension and having the best healthcare a person can have — all of which is included in my pay.

Highlight core benefits and how they support health and financial security

Female Babysitter Watching A Baby At HomeA 2022 Segal survey found that nearly 75 percent of building trade respondents said that unfamiliarity with opportunities and benefits was their greatest challenge in recruiting women. Getting the message right is essential.

It’s useful to mention benefits that women are more likely to use than men, such as maternity/parental leave, childcare/eldercare support and family-friendly benefits, in addition to pre-apprenticeship programs, which were designed to help prepare women and other under-represented groups enter the industry. (We discussed these strategies in the 2022 article, “Recruiting and Retaining Women in the Building Trades.”)

Access to childcare can help women continue to work after they become mothers. In recognition of this need, TradesFutures, a nonprofit that develops, promotes and improves apprenticeship readiness programs, has launched two childcare pilot programs, one in New York City and another in Milwaukee.

However, it’s essential to focus on the core health and retirement benefits that women and men alike appreciate.

Personal health

Young Latin Female Meeting With Her TherapistGive details about the comprehensive healthcare coverage you offer, including dental and vision benefits, as well as wellness programs and mental health/substance use disorder (MH/SUD) benefits. Wellness programs encourage preventive care and promote well-being. MH/SUD services are currently in high demand and the counseling and therapy you provide can help people manage stress anxiety, and other mental health conditions related to caregiving (a responsibly that still disproportionally falls on women) or financial pressures.

Specify cost-sharing requirements and what the out-of-pocket maximum is. If they’re lower than averages in your geographic area, be sure to call attention to that fact. Be specific about how much lower the costs are. A study of the advantage of union membership for healthcare found that being in a union reduces out-of-pocket healthcare costs by between 4.2 and 11.3 percentage points. That’s a powerful selling point.

Mention training on job-site safety that can help prevent on-the-job injuries. Women in construction are at increased risk for injury, according to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. For trainees participating in a Joint Apprentice & Training Committee apprenticeship program, fill coverage gaps.

As women have increased in numbers at construction sites and in labor in general, benefits have been enhanced to often include maternity leave and most recently family-building benefits, such as fertility benefits, adoption, egg harvesting and surrogacy coverage. The cost of these benefits to members is typically less under the plan than the services cost in the general market. If you offer family-building benefits, provide details.

Describe your retiree healthcare coverage. Even young tradeswomen are aware of and appreciate having this benefit, which is an increasingly uncommon offering in other occupations. This valuable coverage offers peace of mind and long-term security.

Retirement readiness

Pregnant Young Woman Working On Laptop With Her Little SonAlthough there’s renewed interest in defined benefit (DB) plans among some employers, the retirement plan design, which provides a guaranteed monthly income through a traditional pension, is still rare in corporate America. Consequently, is a major advantage of working in the unionized sector of the building trades. Call attention to that benefit because a DB plan can go a long way towards providing meaningful retirement income through a steady stream of retirement income.

Research, such as a 2024 survey by the Nationwide Retirement Institute®, has found women are less prepared for retirement than men for several reasons, including they tend to earn less. In general, they are less confident about how to manage their savings. Moreover, many women have breaks in service/savings because they take time away from work for caregiving. Tradeswomen are fortunate to be paid the same as men for identical work. Although workers of both genders who have a DB plan need not worry about making their savings last or saving on their own for retirement, they are still affected by caregiving breaks. A possible solution to address that issue is to provide pension credit for the time that parents are on maternity or paternity leave.

Many unions/trades also offer a DC plan, which is a great companion to the DB plan. During retirement, when retirees are living on a fixed income, DC plan benefits can help them with unanticipated expenses or to offset the impact of inflation on a fixed monthly DB retirement benefit.

Core benefits are the foundation of bringing new recruits into the building trades

Unfamiliarity with opportunities and benefits was the greatest challenge identified in a survey of members of the building trades that we conducted in 2022.

Emphasizing the health and retirement benefits that come with a career in the trades, as well as any financial wellness offerings, will help recruit women (and men) into the construction industry. These benefits give workers peace of mind about their future and their family’s well-being, including a dignified retirement that includes a regular income stream.

The opportunity to gain a skill that leads to a high-paying job, without having to incur the burden of student loan debt, should help cement the deal.

Promote financial wellness

Financial wellness refers to an individual’s financial stability, resiliency, control and choice in meeting their short-term and long-term financial goals.

The fact that women in construction earn nearly as much as men — 99 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics — means their financial situation is strong.

Moreover, since training for a trade through a joint labor-management apprenticeship program is free to apprentices, they start working without becoming saddled with any student loan debt.

Financial wellness benefits, which include education and coaching about personal finance, can help people achieve their financial goals, such as paying off debt and buying a home and saving for emergencies.

Also mention other appealing aspects of working in the building trades

Two Female Construction Workers On A Lunch Break With ColleaguesFrom speaking with women apprentices, we learned about other aspects of working in the building trades, in addition to financial stability, that they like:

  • Paid hands-on, on-the-job training, supplemented by classroom instruction
  • Experienced journeypersons as teachers who help students master challenging skills
  • Working with their hands
  • The opportunity to work outdoors and/or in different locations
  • Creating something tangible
  • Supportive colleagues, including a network of other women who serve as role models
  • Career advancement

These positive characteristics of the work should also be emphasized in your efforts to recruit women.

The timing is right for the right messaging

The good news is that the trades appeal to many members of Generation Z (those born in the late 1990s and early 2000s) who are entering the workforce in large numbers: more than 17 million in 2023. Nearly three-quarters of Gen Zers (73 percent) respect skilled trades as a career, and 47 percent are interested in pursuing a career in a trade, according to a 2023 survey by Thumbtack.

Large Percentages of Generation Z Cite Several Advantages of a Skilled Trade Over a Traditional Office Job

 

 


By the end of this year, the number of Gen Zers in the workforce will overtake the once-dominant baby boomers. Now’s the time to make your case for these new workers to choose a career in the trades.

While it’s not surprising that members of Gen Z, the first generation to grow up in the digital age, use social media when looking for a job, it’s less well known that they look for and trust referrals. So be sure to make your case on social media platforms and feature testimonials from those who are already in the building trades.

Consider communications that speak to recruits in their preferred language. Keep in mind that 30 percent of construction workers were Hispanic in 2020, according to the BLS.

You can get expert advice from Segal Benz communications consultants, who have tech-savvy knowhow, including engaging interactive content, as well as deep knowledge of and experience in how best to speak to each generation of workers. including in multiple languages.

What’s your organization’s strategy for recruiting and retaining women in construction?

We’re interested. Let’s have a conversation.

Get in Touch

The Commerce Department’s CHIPS Women in Construction Framework

CHIPS is shorthand for semiconductors. CHIPS for America implements the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022, which aims to strengthen U.S. semiconductor research, development and manufacturing while investing in American workers.

The CHIPS Women in Construction Framework outlines best practices for recruiting women to the construction industry. Companies that voluntarily adopt the framework will collaborate with contractors, trades unions and other community and workforce partners in their efforts to implement the following practices:

  • Set goals and monitor progress towards increasing the participation of women on CHIPS-funded construction projects.
  • Build community partnerships with community organizations with a track record of increasing women and economically disadvantaged individuals’ exposure to and recruitment into the construction industry.
  • Develop training pathways, such as training investments, apprentice utilization goals or apprentice readiness program partnerships that serve women and economically disadvantaged individuals.
  • Provide access to supportive services, such as childcare or transportation, that will increase retention of women and economically disadvantaged individuals in the workforce.
  • Maintain healthy, safe and respectful workplaces and prevent and address harassment, discrimination, retaliation and violence through workplace training, policy and practice.

The initiative brings together contractors, trade unions and other community and workforce partners. Learn more on the Commerce Department’s website.

Return to the top of this article.

 

See more insights

Female Pharmacist Doing Inventory On A Digital Tablet

What Are the Projected 2025 Health Plan Cost Trends?

Learn projected 2025 health plan cost trends in our October 9 webinar; findings from managed care organizations, health insurers, PBMs and TPAs.
Businessman Talking To An Employee About A Development Project On A Laptop

Multiemployer Pension Plan News for Q3 2024

Multiemployer retirement plan sponsors: Get caught up on 5 hot topics in our brief recap of news impacting multiemployer pension plans.
Stressed Business Woman Working From Home On Laptop Looking Worried

Make a Sound Investment in Supporting Mental Health

Get our handy two-page overview on the importance of mental health coverage to improve participants’ health and help manage your costs.

This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax or investment advice. You are encouraged to discuss the issues raised here with your legal, tax and other advisors before determining how the issues apply to your specific situations.